March 20, 2010 12:33 PM PDT
Scott,
You don't mention how your client is using your station, in terms of his daily frequency and the length of his commitment. Is he on the air daily, all year long (like the client Hal describes), or just buying seasonal flights?
Relying on a big Yellow Pages ad suggests that your client wants to impress the prospect who has no brand preference and is scanning the phone directory to learn what his options are. (You might someday poll your listeners on the question of whether they're more likely to consult a phone book or do an online search for this information and bring this poor fellow the results of your survey...for his own good. Unless he's independently wealthy and has money to burn - literally - he's squandering a lot of money with that passive YP ad...money that could be put to better use with intrusive advertising on your station.)
On the other hand, a HVAC contractor like Hal's client has no need for such an ad; he'd probably agree that it's a waste. Instead, he's chosen to keep his business in front of Hal's listeners every day, telling his story in chapters over and over again, because he realizes that while most listeners are not in the market today, one day they will be, and when they finally are in the market to replace or upgrade an existing system, he'll be the first one that comes to mind, or the one that has made such an impression on them over the years, they made the decision that when the time comes... You know the rest.
That said, your last paragraph suggests that you might have some work to do in uncovering his story. It's possible that every HVAC in your market has access to similar low financing options and rebates as your guy. The fact that they offer "all the usual services" simply puts them into the same pond as every other dealer.
So, why choose him over another dealer? Is there anything that sets him apart from his competition, something he does or offers that his competition doesn't, that would be of value to a prospective customer?
If nothing else, the client himself may be the distinguishing factor...his breadth of experience, the things he does to demonstrate consideration for his customers (e.g., taking steps to prevent their work from messing up a customer's home), some extra service he provides (X_years of free maintenance with purchase of new system), and so forth. Having him voice part of each commercial - a personal invitation or tag line - also would help to set him apart and over time increase your listeners' familiarity with him.
There are many ways to pursue the "WOW" factor (i.e., making a profound impression on your listeners). Doing it with content that actually benefits the listener as a consumer is far more meaningful, in my opinion, than simply trying to create a memorable ad by means of a device or technique that can be replicated for any client in the production studio. (Note: this is not intended as a commentary on Cole's suggestion; there's most certainly a place for memorable copy, jingles, etc., once you've identified the client's USP or distinguishing characteristics or competitive advantages. But great production doesn't take the place of a compelling story.)
Hope this helps.
March 23, 2010 9:11 AM PDT
Just a follow-up to Rod - maybe the angle is your client's ego.
If the YP are an ego buy, then exploit his ego in the copy. But it must be in a way that shows a clear benefit to the target listener. Possibly using the "usual benfits" but adding a line similar to "but with client's reputation for perfection and a full no-questions-asked 36 month guarantee, you'll enjoy the cool breeze for summers to come. Call now, and client will be there tomorrow." (Obviously only include those benefits if the client offers them.)
Best of luck!
March 23, 2010 11:58 AM PDT
Dinosaurs still roam the earth today.
We call them "the Yellow Pages."
;-)
March 24, 2010 9:09 AM PDT
Nice touch!!
March 24, 2010 2:45 PM PDT
Scott,
I create jingles for HVAC Dealers all over the USA. Let me know if you'd like me to send you some samples.
Jim Reilly
[email protected]
732-255-1504